In the executive world, confidence is the currency of the realm. We are paid to have answers, set direction, and project certainty. Consequently, when we feel doubt, we treat it as a defect, a crack in the armor that needs to be hidden or fixed.
But what if your doubt isn’t a weakness? What if it is data?
The most dangerous leaders are not the ones who doubt themselves; they are the ones who don’t. Unchecked confidence leads to Confirmation Bias, the tendency to interpret new evidence as confirmation of one’s existing theories. This is how products launch without market fit and how mergers fail.
To lead at a senior level, you must move beyond “overcoming” doubt and start practicing Strategic Doubt.
The Science: Intellectual Humility
Psychological research defines Intellectual Humility as the recognition that a particular personal belief may be fallible, accompanied by an openness to new information.
Studies published in the Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies suggest that leaders who combine empathy with self-compassion navigate uncertainty more effectively. But it goes deeper than self-compassion. It is about Signal Detection.
Your brain generates doubt for two reasons:
- Noise (Imposter Syndrome): “I am not smart enough to solve this.“
- Signal (Risk Detection): “This solution is too simple for this complex problem.”
The amateur leader tries to silence both. The expert leader learns to filter the Noise so they can hear the Signal.
Case Study: The Automation Trap
I recently coached a leader who was preparing to roll out a major initiative: automating a burdensome demand planning process. On paper, it was the perfect solution. It was efficient, modern, and logical.
But she had a nagging doubt.
A traditional “confidence” approach would have told her to ignore the feeling, push through the imposter syndrome, and execute. Instead, we engaged in Strategic Doubt. She paused the rollout to interrogate the feeling.
She asked, “Is this even the right problem?”
By slowing down, she realized that the team’s resistance wasn’t due to the manual process; it was due to profound role misalignment and fatigue. Automating the process wouldn’t have fixed the burnout; it would have accelerated it.
Because she listened to her doubt, she pivoted. She addressed the role clarity first. The automation came later, and it succeeded. If she had been “confident,” she would have failed.
The Protocol: How to Audit Your Doubt
When you feel that familiar pit in your stomach, do not suppress it. Run it through this three-step audit:
1. Isolate the Source (Signal vs. Noise)
Ask yourself: “Am I doubting my competence, or am I doubting the plan?”
- If you are doubting your competence (“They’ll find out I’m a fraud”), that is Noise. Apply self-compassion and regulation techniques to get back online.
- If you are doubting the plan (“We haven’t accounted for X”), that is Signal. That is a strategic asset.
2. The Pre-Mortem
This is a concept popularized by Daniel Kahneman. Assume the project has failed six months from now. Ask: “What did my doubt see that I refused to look at?” This creates psychological safety for your own brain to explore the risks without feeling like a pessimist.
3. Model Fallibility
When you admit to your team, “I am 80% confident in this, but here is the 20% that worries me,” you do not look weak. You look accurate. You signal to your team that it is safe to spot risks. You turn your team from a group of “Yes Men” into a group of “Risk Detectors.”
The Bottom Line
Doubt is uncomfortable, but comfort is not the goal of leadership. Effectiveness is.
The next time you feel uncertain, don’t try to “fix” it. Lean into it. Your doubt might just be the only thing standing between you and a very expensive mistake.
Upgrade Your Decision Making
Navigating the gap between “Imposter Syndrome” and “Strategic Insight” is difficult to do alone. As an executive coach, I help leaders filter the noise so they can act on the signal.
If you want to sharpen your decision-making architecture, let’s connect.
Pingback: Receiving Feedback: An Essential Checklist for Leaders - Amy Kay Watson